Fogo Island, my love — I miss you.

It has been 22 months since I visited Newfoundland and Labrador, unwinding on the deck at what my family calls “our Puffin House,” hiking to see the Great Auk statue or Brimstone Head (a lookout that’s cheekily promoted as one of the four corners of the flat earth), watching my kids swim in the Atlantic Ocean at Fogo Island’s one sandy beach, eating at least one partridgeberry and Jam Jams cookie crumble ice cream cone a day from Growlers, and chatting, endlessly chatting, with people I know and people I don’t.

Fogo Island Inn: on the island off an island

Fogo Island Inn

Fogo Island Inn

Fogo swept me away the first time I visited “the island off an island” that cold February in 2017 to celebrate Canada’s 150th birthday year.

I remember the way my perpetually racing mind slowed as the ferry crunched its way through the ice from Farewell to the island, and how I happily got lost driving around trying to find the Fogo Island Inn because there weren’t any signs pointing the way. That’s the Fogo way — the journey is just as important as the destination, and if you want to know something, you just have to ask.

Like many, I vaguely pictured the world-famous, architecturally astounding inn sitting alone on a remote, rocky and windswept island — because that’s the way it’s usually photographed — and was embarrassed to find more than 2,200 people spread out over nearly a dozen small but vibrant communities.

The inn matched me with lovely cultural host, Blanche Dawe Bennett — a local who’s hired to give you a memorable, half-day experience as part of your stay — and sent me cabin-hopping, snowmobiling and ice-fishing with the tight-knit Foley clan who sang classic Irish songs while I cursed myself for being tone-deaf and unable to join in.

I quickly learned how the inn, while it is a splurge and draws international guests, is a social business run by Shorefast, a charity that builds economic and cultural resilience on the island, and also runs the Woodshop on Fogo and Fogo Island Fish. I became smitten with warm white bread with butter and molasses, which is delivered to your room with tea as soon as you arrive.

And impulse purchase

The author's house and shed in Joe Batt's Arm

The author’s house and shed in Joe Batt’s Arm

Wherever I went, I was shown all the homes that were quietly up for sale, most without signs in the yard, or real estate agents or even set prices, because that’s the Fogo way. It’s a negotiation that you must handle on your own.

When people ask how I ended up with a vacation home on an island off an island half a country away from where I live in Toronto, I tell them how I dragged my family back to Fogo for Mother’s Day three months after my first visit, how happy we were at the inn, how we looked for icebergs and how we impulsively bought a house in Joe Batt’s Arm with views of the inn, the ocean and a shallow, rocky pond that’s always filled with birds.

Marc Fiset in the Fogo Island Metalworks shop

Marc Fiset in the Fogo Island Metalworks shop

Linda and Winston Osmond in front of Herring Cove Art Gallery and Studio in Shoal Bay

Linda and Winston Osmond of Herring Cove Art Gallery and Studio in Shoal Bay

That summer we returned (with a truck full of furniture) and I finally saw my first puffin on a boat trip to the abandoned fishing colony on Little Fogo Island. My kids met the pigs and chickens that artist Winston Osmond keeps near his Herring Cove Art Gallery and Studio in Shoal Bay, and we ordered a quilt made by Winston’s wife Linda. We commissioned a painting from artist M’Liz Keefe and a firepit from Marc Fiset of Fogo Island Metalworks.

I’ll admit that we don’t have a charming Newfoundland “saltbox house,” but we made up for it by cladding our place in local spruce, painted bright orange with white trim because the colours remind me of puffins, the clowns of the sea. (We threw in a purple door which admittedly has no puffin connection.)

Introducing friends & family to Fogo Island

Exploring sites on Fogo Island

introducing friends and family to Fogo Island: clockwise from top left — the author’s son on Devil’s Rocking Chair, old School House Museum, Fogo Island hiking trail, Mona’s Quilt shop, Great Auk statue, exploring Little Fogo Island

Over the next few years, I visited Fogo Island whenever I could with friends and family, trips that were now highlighted by meals at my favourite new island restaurants called Bangbelly Café and Scoff (and sometimes even dinner at the inn, if it wasn’t filled with guests, or fresh lobster from the fish plant). When I couldn’t go, I lent my Puffin House to others, to spread the Fogo love.

Long Studio on Fogo Island CREDIT Jennifer Bain

Long Studio on Fogo Island

I got into a routine of taking people on that boat trip to the puffin colony, and on easy hikes to see the studios that Shorefast uses for international residencies through Fogo Island Arts (and that sometimes are mistakenly used in stories about the inn), and to see my favourite weathered bronze statue of a Great Auk, a flightless seabird that’s now extinct.

I showed off the island’s free-ranging caribou herd and its small assortment of sheep, and eventually met Al Dwyer who hosts a walking tour of Tilting and Oliver’s Cove that ends at a rock formation called the Devil’s Rocking Chair followed by a few songs at his “shed” (a gathering place). His brother Roy Dwyer writes books full of local tales.

So much more to discover

Distant view of the Town of Fogo on Fogo Island

Town of Fogo

People say that Tilting is now more Irish than Ireland, and it has been designated a National Historic Site because of its Irish heritage, but I haven’t had time to really dig into that. And although it might seem like there’s not much to do on a tiny island, I only just started visiting all of Fogo’s dozen or so tiny museums, like the Marine Interpretation Centre, and places like the Fogo Island Geology Centre and the Punt Premises that showcases the small wooden fishing boats that have been so important to life here.

When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, Canada closed its borders to the world, Newfoundland and Labrador closed its doors to most Canadians (except for those in what was called “the Atlantic bubble”) and I could only wistfully connect with Fogo through Facebook friends and groups. If there’s one thing that this magical island has taught me though, it’s patience. I will return — when the time is right.

Partiridgeberry and Jam Jams cookie ice cream cone from Growlers

Partiridgeberry and Jam Jams cookie ice cream cone from Growlers

What’s appealing to an over-50 traveler?

  • In Joe Batt’s Arm, the Fogo Island Inn has just 29 rooms and rates include meals, a half-day island orientation with a community host and most excursions. It’s a non-tipping community enterprise. The inn hopes to reopen July 2 for guests from within Canada in accordance with provincial regulations.
  • In Tilting, the Tilting Harbour Bed and Breakfast is housed in an authentic saltbox house. It has two queen rooms and two double rooms, all with private bathrooms and a full breakfast.
  • Settled accommodation for the duration of the trip
  • Opportunities to customize a trip with activities based on the season and traveler preferences

Take note

  • Getting to Fogo Island is a journey that usually involves a flight to St. John’s or Gander and then a car rental. A ferry that runs several times a day connects Farewell and the island. There are no reservations and so you usually need to get in the lineup at least an hour before the departure time.
  • There is no public transportation on the island, so a rental car is essential for exploring.

COVID-19 Update Info: What You Need to Know

  • Take note of temporary closures, travel advisories and other restrictions put in place because of the pandemic.
  • Canada is not currently open to leisure travelers, but that status is subject to change. Current rules on visiting Newfoundland and Labrador.


Photo credits: All photos Jennifer Bain


The author owns a vacation home on Fogo Island.

Previously on GettingOnTravel:

Another special destination on Canada’s West Coast

Things To Do in Tofino, Canada’s Storm-Watching Capital

Save to Pinterest!!

Love Letter to Fogo Island